 |
Peggy Lee is to Nat King Cole |
 |
what Sarah Vaughan is to Mel Torme |
 |
while Carmen McRae is to Sammy Davis |
 |
what Billie Holiday is to Bill Henderson |
 |
and so, if Ella Fitzgerald is to Frank Sinatra |
 |
who might be the counterpart to Dinah Washington ...
|
 |
answer: Ray Charles (like Dinah, Ray has taken his share of
criticism for "selling out" ... neglecting his genius for the more common
musical delights.) |
Tony Bennett, Lena Horne, Anita O'Day, Johnny Hartmann, Betty Carter
Dinah was not a song stylist in the vaulted tradition of Carmen et al... Widely regarded as one of the 4 greatest female jazz singers.... (I'd add
Carmen McRae, and make it 5) ... but her notariety is not nearly that of the
prinicipal three, Billie, Sarah, Ella. Why not the same attention as billie,
sarah, ella ??
Dinah was hardly proper -- only in song was her expression flawless /
impeccable ...
(Vulgar ... not tragic ... boisterous ... --- Dinah was not aloof;
possessed few affectations; and made no effort to suppress or conceal a
decidedly earthy, folksy demeanor)
not a chanteuse or diva in the true sense (she poked as much fun as she took
pride in her designation as queen)
... not as beautiful (in fact, regarded as homely ... though if she had lived in
the present-day, Dinah would likely be regarded utterly attractive and
vivacious, if not a rather sexy full-figured woman) ... Sarah, Ella, and Billie
were in any case each more widely regarded as good-looking and classy.
... but for legitimate reasons stemming from the nature of her career.
... all over the map (consistency…)
... race singer (popular w/negro audience) .. unlike her peers,
she did not front for a major bandleader for any serious stay
... the label saw a better opportunity in making Dinah more of a personality ...
a culturally welcome and familiar voice ... (Lionel Hampton)
... quest for larger fame/audience/impact ...popularity (an obsession which
managed to suffocate once vital performers such as ... ) ... undermines one's
craft
Largely speaking, it was a strategy that worked ... Despite her relatively
brief devotion to negro blues, Dinah inherited (from Bessie Smith) the title
Queen of the Blues ... it was a self-adorned alias which would never fall to
question. Moreover at the midpoint of her career, she was easily the most
financially successful female singer alive -- beginning a long and steady string
of jukebox hits and continuing through her richly musical Emarcy period.
No scat, no slur ... one of the most consistently on-key singers (on record
and in person). Although her speech and pronunciation was, when speaking,
shoddy and decidedly colloquial .. her song presentation was sterling .. her
diction impeccable. There is but one mistake she is known to have made ...
(her second recording of her #2 all-time hit I Wanna Be Loved ... in which she
transposes the plural noun in the phrase ... when our heartbeats intermingle ..
hearts beat intermingle (passable poetry)
Dinah: I could sing anything, anything at all!
Quincy Jones:
Leonard Feather:
Abbey Lincoln:
Diane Schuur:
The Queen of the Blues ?
The Swingin' Miss D. ?
Godmother to Patti, Aretha
What a Difference a Day Made?